Has depth thinned since the 29 Oct 2026 hack, and did it drive the weekend liquidations? · snapshot 2026-11-16
1 · Have the books thinned? Yes — materially.
Cost to execute a $5m market order (one-way VWAP slippage, averaged buy/sell):
Window
Spot bps
Perp bps
BTC px
Liquidations
Pre-hack (22–28 Oct)
3.7
1.6
80,900
$29m/day
Hack week (29 Oct–4 Nov)
4.4
1.7
78,100
$66m/day
Mid (5–13 Nov)
4.6
2.0
74,500
$66m/day
Weekend (14–15 Nov)
6.2
3.1
65,600
$122m/day
This morning (16 Nov)
5.7
2.5
64,700
—
Spot slippage is up ~70% and perp ~95% (roughly doubled) vs the
pre-hack baseline — resting depth for a $5m clip has roughly halved on the perp. Perp stays ~2× deeper
than spot throughout (expected — the more liquid venue).
2 · Did thin books cause the weekend liquidations? The data does not prove it.
What the data shows: weekend liquidations ran ~$122m/day vs ~$29m/day pre-hack (4×),
and thinning vs liquidations are only weakly correlated hourly (+0.27). Two problems with the theory:
The causal arrow more likely runs the other way. Forced liquidations are market sells that consume
the book and drag price down — which is what thins it. Thin books and liquidations co-occur because the cascade
eats the depth, not because pre-existing thinness triggered the liquidations (those fire on price/margin). $5m at
6 bps is still cheap — nowhere near enough friction to force anyone out.
The thinning tracks the price decline, not the hack. There is no step-change at 29 Oct
(perp impact 1.6→1.7 bps that week). The real thinning came with the 13–15 Nov drawdown (75k→65k). Both the thin
books and the liquidations are symptoms of the same post-hack risk-off regime and falling price.
Bottom line. Books have genuinely thinned (~2× worse $5m slippage) and weekend
liquidations were elevated (~4×), and they move together — but this is common-cause co-movement, not
thin-books-caused-liquidations. If anything, the liquidation cascade drives the thinning more than the reverse.